Diet and Violence
The CNP Diet and Violence Research Category consolidates research exploring the interdependent relationship between dietary intake and violence. To view each original study on the open internet, click “Original.” To view the CNP-written abstract summary, click “CNP Summary.” While only some of the CNP-written abstract summaries are available below for free, all abstract summaries are available to CNP members through the CNP Library Membership.
FEATURED CNP RESEARCH SUMMARY
In this 2013 study, Gesch tests the hypothesis that poor diet is one of the factors that predispose an individual to develop antisocial behaviors. This study supplied violent young adult prisoners between the ages of 18-21 with food supplements to ensure consumption of nutrients that were lacking before. The supplement capsules contained the daily requirements of vitamins, minerals, and essential fatty acids. The 231 volunteers were randomly selected to either receive the supplement capsule or a placebo. The number of offenses committed by each prisoner before and while taking the supplement was documented. Those prisoners who were given nutrients committed significantly (26.3%) fewer offenses than those who consumed the placebo. There was also a 37% reduction in the number of most serious crimes committed by the inmates given real supplements. Furthermore, another double-blind study conducted by the Dutch Ministry of Justice replicated these findings. Further replication would confirm a simple and humane way to reduce and prevent violence and antisocial behaviour. This study supports providing people in jail with a more nutritious diet since the only risk is better health. [NPID: violence, antisocial, loneliness, prison, prisoners, fatty acids]
2022
Nutrition availability for those incarcerated in jail: Implications for mental health
In this study by Mommaerts et al. (2022), the authors evaluated the availability of micronutrients known to be connected to mental health problems in a seven-day cycle menu and supplies available in stores within a prison facility. The nutritional value of the seven-day cycle of meals and four commissary food packets (breakfast, dinner, snacks, and sweets) available for consumption by incarcerated individuals was assessed and compared to dietary reference intakes (DRI). Analysis of the micronutrients demonstrated that DRI guidelines were satisfied for Zinc and vitamins B12, C, and B6 mean values in the menu. However, the DRI guidelines were not met for omega-3 fatty acids, magnesium (for males only), or vitamin D (for both males and females). Because bipolar disorder, anxiety, and depression are known to be exacerbated by deficiencies in vitamin D, magnesium, and omega-3 fatty acids, the authors conclude that modest dietary adjustments could increase the availability and possible consumption of nutrients that may enhance mental health in prison settings. [NPID: Jail, mental health, nutrition, psychological services, commissary]
CNP Research Summary can be found in the CNP Library Membership
2020
Omega-3 supplementation, child antisocial behavior, and psychopathic personality: A randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled, stratified, parallel group trial
Raine et al. (2020) conducted this study to investigate the effect of omega-3 supplementation on social behavior and its efficacy from a psychopathic personality and gender point of view. Using a sample of 320 school children aged 11.9 years on average, the participants were divided into three distinct groups: a treatment group (n = 108), a placebo group (n = 110) and a no-treatment group (n = 106). During the six months’ duration of the study, parent and child reports on antisocial and aggressive behavior were collected at the start and at the end of the study, and after six months of the study’s conclusion. Analysis of the study groups, gender and timeline, revealed that omega-3 supplementation lead to a substantial decrease in antisocial behavior at the end of the study period in female participants only, and that the beneficial impact of omega-3 on antisocial behavioral traits was substantially noted in children whom had a preexisting high psychopathic-like personality. Thus, the authors conclude that omega-3 supplementation may help reduce antisocial and aggressive behavior traits in females, especially those who possess a psychopathic-like personality. [NPID: aggression, antisocial, omega-3, psychopathy, randomized controlled trial]
2016
Association of breakfast intake with psychiatric distress and violent behaviors in Iranian children and adolescents: The CASPIAN- IV Study
In this study by Ahadi et al. (2016), the authors investigated whether eating or skipping breakfast is related to psychiatric ailments or violent conduct in children and adolescents. 14,880 students aged between 6-18 years old were selected from both urban and rural areas, and data on breakfast consumption, psychiatric distress, and violent conduct was collected via questionnaires modeled after the Global school-based student health survey of the World Health Organization. Analysis of the results revealed that psychiatric distress and violent behavior were notably more prevalent amongst students who skipped breakfast compared to those who did not skip breakfast consistently or only skipped breakfast on occasion. In addition, students who skipped breakfast were more likely to report feeling victimized, and engaged in more physical altercations compared to their peers. The authors conclude that students who have breakfast consistently suffer less mental stress and behavioral disorders, and that regular balanced diets, coupled with increasing parent/guardian awareness on the benefits of having breakfast, presents a suitable intervention to prevent mental health disorders and violent conduct in children and adolescents. [NPID: Breakfast, bullying, children and adolescents, psychiatric, violence]
CNP Research Summary can be found in the CNP Library Membership
2002
Influence of supplementary vitamins, minerals and essential fatty acids on the antisocial behaviour of young adult prisoners. Randomised, placebo-controlled trial
This is a randomized placebo-controlled trial from 2002 that checked whether adding nutritional value to young adult prisoners’ diets can positively affect their behavior. There was already evidence indicating that offenders’ lack of essential nutrients in their diets may adversely influence their behaviors. The 231 prisoners were randomly allocated to either receive a placebo capsule or a supplement of vitamins, minerals and essential fatty acids. Comparing the subjects’ disciplinary offences before and during supplementation, those participants given nutritional supplements were found to commit 26.3% fewer offences on average, compared with those prisoners consuming placebos. Compared to the baseline disciplinary records, supplement consumption for a minimum of 2 weeks saw an average 35.1% reduction in offences. However, these statistics stayed within standard error for the placebo group. Gesch et al. therefore concluded that increasing intakes of vitamins, minerals and essential fatty acids can reduce antisocial behavior within prisons. [NPID: violence, prison, prisoners, vitamins, minerals, essential fatty acids, fatty acids]
2020
The effect of dietary supplementation on aggressive behaviour in Australian adult male prisoners: A feasibility and pilot study for a randomised, double blind placebo controlled trial
In this 2020 randomized controlled trial, adult male prisoners were randomly given either omega-3 long chain polyunsaturated fatty acids (n-3 LCPUFA) and multivitamin supplements or a placebo to determine the effect of nutritional supplements on aggressive behavior. While 136 adult males signed up for the 16-week trial, 60% stayed for the experiment. The measures of aggressive behavior [institutional records of misconduct (IRM), the Inmate Behaviour Observation Scale (IBOS)] were collected for all of the participants, while 82-97% completed the questionnaires (also to examine aggressiveness) and 93% of blood samples (to inspect erythrocyte n-3 LCPUFA levels) were successfully collected. Prisoners were 4.3 times more likely to have an IBOS over 2 if they are below the 6% cut off on the omega-3 index. But Cortie et al. could not identify any significant differences in outcomes between the supplement group and the placebo group, with both groups improving overall across all measures. A greater sample size of 600 subjects was suggested by a power calculation, to detect the impact of dietary supplementation on aggressive behavior. [NPID: violence, omega-3s, polyunsaturated fatty acids, multivitamin, prison, prisoners]
CNP Research Summary can be found in the CNP Library Membership
2017
Violence exposure and adolescents' same-day obesogenic behaviors: New findings and a replication
The aim of this 2017 study was to find out if exposure to violence leads to increased obesogenic behaviors (unhealthy food and beverage consumption, poor quality sleep, and lack of physical activity) among young adolescents. Piontak et al. signed up at-risk adolescents between 12 and 15 years of age via telephone screening from low-income neighborhoods. Assessments were carried out in-person with both the adolescent and their parents before Ecological Momentary Assessments (EMAs) were sent to the 151 adolescents' mobile phones three times a day for 30 days. Compared to days of no exposure, on days in which the adolescents were exposed to violence, higher odds of consuming unhealthy foods and beverages were observed, in addition to increased activeness and reports of tiredness the next morning. Further analysis revealed that at-risk individuals who showed higher intakes of soda and caffeinated beverages during the 30-day EMA were more likely to grow in BMI in later adolescence. Although no significant same-day associations were found between violence exposure and unhealthy dietary consumption, sleep- and activity-related findings were backed up by the population-based replication sample that included 395 adolescents. To summarize, violence exposure was related with same-day unhealthy dietary consumption among at-risk adolescents and next-day tiredness related to sleep quality among adolescents from both at-risk and normative populations. There were also signs that unhealthy soda consumption during early adolescence can predict weight gain among at-risk adolescents. [NPID: violence, obesity, sleep, sleep quality, low income, soda, adolescence]
2021
Diet quality and physical fighting among youth: A cross-national study
This 2021 study explores the possible link between diet quality and physical fighting during early adolescence. The data analyzed came from the 2005/2006 Health Behaviors of School Children (HBSC) survey. Jackson & Vaughn reveal the 40% increase in physical fighting among youths with lower quality diets, relative to youths with better diets. These school children were also 68% more likely to partake in frequent physical fighting if their diets were low in quality than if their diets were better. This association between diet quality and physical fighting was consistent in 38 of the 40 countries examined and was found to be even stronger among the female sample. The strategy for discouraging physical fighting among adolescents may be to design strategies aimed at enhancing the youths’ diet quality. [NPID: violence, physical fighting, diet quality, youth, adolescence]
CNP Research Summary can be found in the CNP Library Membership
2021
Violence, aggression and our food
This 2021 editorial presents evidence from the literature of the link between inadequate nutrition and the development of aggressive behavior. To begin, Brown provides a summary of previous studies demonstrating associations between optimal intake of a diverse variety of vitamins and minerals, with reduced violent and aggressive behavior in children, adolescents, and adults. Then, this article discusses a particular conceptual model by which environmental factors such as a person’s social environment and the quality of soils collectively contribute to low nutrient status and changes in neurological function leading to modified behavior including violence and aggression. The study of this connection between malnutrition and psychiatric and behavioral disorders can give rise to enhanced treatments as well as the potential for lower-cost therapy and improved patient outcomes. [NPID: violence, aggression, neurological function, malnutrition]
2018
The bully-victim overlap and nutrition among school-aged youth in North America and Europe
This 2018 study was conducted to investigate whether there is any correlation between dietary patterns among youth, bully perpetration, and bully victimization. Jackson & Vaughn examined around 150,000 youths, aged 10–16, from 40 different countries, noting the prevalence of bully victimization and perpetration as well as dietary information. Nutritional assessment was based on the adolescents’ meal deprivation and consumptions of healthy and junk foods. These 3 nutritional variables were found to be significantly associated with bully perpetration, regardless of whether bullying co-occurred with victimization. Those who ate low quantities of healthy foods were at a 24% higher risk of bullying others, while high junk food intake and frequently depriving oneself of meals were linked with 66% and 48% higher likelihood of taking part in bullying, respectively. However, there was no connection between any of the 3 dietary dimensions with odds of being a victim of bullying. These findings indicate that youths who are deprived of meals regularly and eat high levels of junk foods and low amounts of healthy foods, are more than twice as likely to bully others, in comparison with those youths who report none of these 3 dietary problems. A strategy for reducing bullying rates among youths may be to implement dietary interventions that diminish hunger and enhance eating behaviors. [NPID: violence, bullying, meal deprivation, junk food]
CNP Research Summary can be found in the CNP Library Membership
2013
Adolescence: Does good nutrition = good behaviour?
Gesch (2013) tested the hypothesis that poor diet is one of the factors that predispose an individual to develop antisocial behaviors. This study supplied violent young adult prisoners between the ages of 18-21 with food supplements to ensure consumption of nutrients that were lacking before. The supplement capsules contained the daily requirements of vitamins, minerals, and essential fatty acids. The 231 volunteers were randomly selected to either receive the supplement capsule or a placebo. The number of offenses committed by each prisoner before and while taking the supplement was documented. Those prisoners who were given nutrients committed significantly (26.3%) fewer offenses than those who consumed the placebo. There was also a 37% reduction in the number of most serious crimes committed by the inmates given real supplements. Furthermore, another double-blind study conducted by the Dutch Ministry of Justice replicated these findings. Further replication would confirm a simple and humane way to reduce and prevent violence and antisocial behaviour. This study supports providing people in jail with a more nutritious diet since the only risk is better health. [NPID: violence, antisocial, loneliness, prison, prisoners, fatty acids]
2019
You may be what you eat, can you be violent due to your food?
While there have been studies analyzing the relationship between micronutrients and antisocial behaviors, Du (2019) focuses on the influence of specific food types and dietary patterns on violent behaviors. The study notes that certain foods are associated with an increase in violence, namely junk food (westernized diet), coffee, soda, and chocolates. These foods disrupt brain development, neurochemical metabolism, and communication among neurotransmitters such as serotonin and dopamine. Dietary patterns have also been linked with more violent behaviors. Additionally, those individuals oblivious to their milk or natural salicylate intolerance tend to show increased violent habits. The replacement of these violence-inducing foods at schools, companies, and prisons is possible and may help prevent violence and cut down on antisocial behaviors. [NPID: violence, micronutrients, antisocial, loneliness, junk food, WS diet, Western-style diet, coffee, soda, chocolate, neurochemical metabolism, serotonin, dopamine, salicylate, prison]